Officer Scott Mathews – Aurora, CO

Former Colorado Department of Corrections Officer and Army National Guard veteran Scott Mathews dedicated his career to serving his country and maintaining public safety. Today, Scott Mathews is serving a 37-year prison sentence following a fatal confrontation outside his Aurora, Colorado, apartment in 2019. From the start, Scott has maintained that he acted in self-defense after being physically attacked. Now, with his conviction upheld and his freedom at stake, Scott and his family are fighting for another opportunity to challenge his conviction and seek justice.

Scott Mathews proudly served in the Army National Guard and later worked as a corrections officer with the Colorado Department of Corrections. His mother, Theresa Kirk, describes a young man who took pride in wearing the uniform and fulfilling his responsibilities to protect others. But on July 4, 2019, shortly after completing an eight-hour shift, Scott became involved in a confrontation outside his apartment complex that would forever change his life.

On July 4, 2019, Scott and his partner, Katherine O’Neal, encountered neighbors setting off fireworks near their Aurora apartment. Concerned about their frightened dogs, the couple became involved in a heated disagreement with neighbor Shamira Cotton. The argument quickly escalated into a physical altercation. According to Scott’s family, Cotton struck him in the head with a glass container, leaving him injured and bleeding. Cotton’s partner, Jaharie Wheeler, then entered the confrontation and struck Scott in the face.

Scott Mathews feared for his life when Wheeler allegedly reached for his holstered firearm. Believing he was in immediate danger, Scott drew his weapon and fired a single shot, fatally wounding Wheeler. Scott remained at the scene and acknowledged firing the shot.

The prosecution presented a different account, arguing that Scott had escalated the confrontation by threatening Cotton with his firearm and initiating physical contact before Wheeler intervened. Although Scott maintained that he acted in self-defense, the incident resulted in an unjust murder charges and the loss of his law enforcement career.

In December 2021, an Arapahoe County jury convicted Scott of second-degree murder, felony menacing, and third-degree assault. In April 2022, Scott was sentenced to 37 years in the Colorado Department of Corrections.

Serious problems with his legal representation prevented him from receiving an adequate defense. His original retained attorney withdrew before trial, leaving Scott struggling to secure replacement counsel and the resources necessary to investigate his case. Scott had contacted dozens of attorneys but could not afford their substantial fees. Although new attorneys eventually agreed to represent him, he and his family maintain they lacked sufficient time and investigative resources to prepare.

On December 26, 2024, the Colorado Court of Appeals upheld Scott’s conviction, rejecting his appellate arguments concerning court-appointed counsel, trial continuances, and prosecutorial misconduct.

Although the appellate court upheld Scott’s conviction, his family continues seeking legal assistance to evaluate possible post-conviction relief, including claims related to ineffective assistance of counsel. Scott’s mother’s greatest hope is that her son will receive every fair opportunity the law allows to challenge his conviction and one day return home.

NCPD is committed to helping Scott and his family seek a thorough review of their legal options and supporting their continued efforts to obtain a fair resolution. Scott Mathews has already spent years behind bars, and his mother continues fighting for the opportunity to bring her son home.

Pursuing post-conviction relief requires legal expertise, investigative work, and significant financial resources that Scott and his family cannot shoulder alone, so the National Center for Police Defense is asking supporters to stand with Scott and his family during this difficult legal battle.

Your generous donation will help NCPD support Scott’s continuing legal fight and assist other law enforcement officers and families facing serious legal challenges.

Please consider making a donation today to help Scott Mathews and his family continue their pursuit of justice.

DONATE TODAY: https://nationalcenterforpolicedefense.com/donate/